CMO PUBLIC COMPANY LIMITEDSET: CMO🇹🇭 TH

Risk Management · 2024

Risk Management Policy & Plan

Policy & Plan Description

Risk Management Policy and Plan


CMO Public Company Limited recognizes the importance of risk management and has established a risk management policy based on internationally accepted principles, namely the COSO (The Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission) Enterprise Risk Management Framework 2017, as a framework for managing risks within the company. This framework helps prevent damage and increases the chances of achieving business objectives and goals effectively. The company closely monitors and assesses risks related to business operations, including strategic, operational, financial liquidity, legal, regulatory, environmental, technological, and data security risks. The company has established a Risk Management Committee to oversee enterprise-wide risk management to ensure effective, timely, and acceptable risk management. The Risk Management Committee is responsible for assessing and controlling risks across the organization and regularly reporting the results to the Audit Committee to prepare for and find ways to prevent and manage risks in various areas that may affect future business operations.

Risks to the Company's Business Operations

Risk Register

Risk NameRisk CharacteristicsConsequencesManagement MeasuresRelated Risk Factors
Risks arising from uncertainties in economic, social, urban, and government policy changes.

The creative service and event organizing business is related to and linked with the advertising and public relations business, which is highly correlated with the overall economic situation of the country. Consumer spending and business survival are key factors for product and service owners in deciding to use various advertising and public relations media, including marketing events or events as a marketing tool to promote sales.


When consumer goods have the general public as their target group, and in Thai society, the public is alert and interested in the political situation, business operations are directly affected by the changing political and overall economic climate of the country.

Political stability, protests by various groups, economic policies, inflation rates, interest rates, tax rates, including unemployment rates, all result in the reconsideration of marketing policies, budget allocation for advertising and public relations, as well as event budgets. This is not to mention the policies of various projects that are directly established and supported by the government and jointly promoted by the private sector, such as large-scale projects related to event organization, tourism promotion projects, and international conference organization projects, which are quite sensitive to the political and economic situation. These may also have policy changes to align with the circumstances at that time. In addition, tourism is a key factor that directly affects the event industry in Thailand, as both international and domestic tourists play a role in stimulating the economy of event-related businesses. However, in recent years, the tourism industry has faced many challenges that have affected the overall event business. Although tourism in Thailand has recovered continuously, there are still limitations from external factors such as the global economic situation. Including competitor countries in Southeast Asia such as Singapore, Malaysia, and Vietnam, which have developed strong infrastructure and policies to attract tourists, causing Thailand to face intense competition. At the same time, domestic consumption has contracted.

The Company is always prepared for this situation by attempting to allocate revenue generation to not rely on any particular customer, whether it be the public or private sector. Instead, the Company strives to diversify its customer base across various industries and regions of the country. The Company does not limit its operations to the capital city, nor does it rely on any single customer or specific industry. It distributes revenue generation according to market conditions. In addition, the Company has a policy of maintaining a balance of work that will generate revenue equitably and with the utmost prudence. This includes establishing a policy to create recurring revenue streams for the Company, such as undertaking construction and museum management projects. The Company has also implemented an operating cost management policy to strictly reduce expenses, along with expediting internal work processes to reduce overall costs. This ensures sufficient cash flow for the Company to continue its operations. The Company is also adapting its business model to suit the current situation, maximizing opportunities and minimizing obstacles in its business operations.


728 · Description: Volatility in the industry in which the company operates · Info category: STRATEGIC_RISK · 730 · Description: Government policy · Info category: STRATEGIC_RISK
Emerging risks that may impact the company's business operations in the next 3-5 years and technological advancements.

Technological advancements are rapidly changing in the present day. Trends or popularity among consumers in the Western world can be widely recognized and spread to the Eastern world in a short time. With increasingly advanced technologies, especially after the Coronavirus disease (COVID-19) pandemic, technological advancements are another factor driving rapid change. Therefore, working to meet the needs and create experiences for customer groups in the marketing business, it is inevitable that changes and increases in technology will affect the company's business operations.

Customers have more options for organizing events. If the company does not develop its event formats to be modern, unique, or trendy, including studying and adopting new technologies to be used in organizing events to keep up with the digital world, the company may lose market share to competitors.

The company has developed and promoted the quality of event work to be even more advanced. By embracing new technologies that align with events, having a team to take care of customers and provide close consultation, the company consistently creates quality events with new perspectives that benefit the business of client companies. This includes finding new marketing tools or collaborating with technology owners to jointly drive and transfer knowledge that helps strengthen and enable sustainable business operations in the future.


In addition to events, the company also has plans to cope with technological changes by adapting current modern technology to enhance operational potential. This includes studying new technologies expected to emerge in the future to build confidence and meet the diverse needs of customers.

732 · Description: Changes in technologies · Info category: STRATEGIC_RISK
Risks arising from changes in customer marketing plans and shifting consumer behavior

After the COVID-19 situation, it is undeniable that consumer behavior has changed significantly due to the adaptation to new lifestyles. The company has adjusted its strategy by increasing the format of online events in conjunction with On Ground events. By creating a Studio with modern tools to support all forms of events, including Virtual Experience, to meet the diverse needs of customers and better align with changing consumer behavior.

This has a significant impact on consumer behavior, which has changed dramatically due to the need to adapt to new lifestyles. As a result, the company has to adjust its event format to include both online and on-ground events to support a wider range of customers.

With over 30 years of continuous business operation, the company has a customer base from both the public and private sectors in a variety of industries, which have different event schedules. This is considered a diversification of risk in terms of event timing. In addition, the company has a policy of finding new customers in a variety of industries both domestically and internationally, such as museum management, learning center management, and museum construction. If an event occurs that causes the company's event activities to be halted, this group will be considered the least affected or unaffected group. This is considered risk management in accordance with changes in the market and consumer behavior so that the business can respond to customer needs effectively and grow sustainably in the future.

729 · Description: Behavior or needs of customers / consumers · Info category: STRATEGIC_RISK
Changes in the industry in which the business operates

Currently, entrepreneurs who are already involved in client businesses, such as advertising agencies, print media companies, and television programs, as well as entrepreneurs who are not involved in client businesses, such as public relations companies, have begun to adapt and create value in the event management market. This is due to the significantly increasing market value of the event management business each year. By leveraging the strengths of their existing businesses and integrating them with event management, the growth of these businesses has resulted in intensified competition within the event industry. However, the company believes that organizing various types of events requires specific experience and expertise. Although these businesses may establish event departments to oversee and manage events, primarily for cost-saving purposes, their personnel's expertise may not meet the needs of clients or deliver events of comparable standards to companies specializing in this field.

The event market still sees movements from entrepreneurs or former clients who have accumulated experience and learned from events organized by their companies or other event companies. They have adapted, learned, and organized events themselves without relying on event management companies that specialize in this field. Therefore, the current event industry not only faces increased competition but also needs to adapt and maintain high quality. At the same time, it must build acceptance from clients based on the success of its events and continuously develop its potential in terms of service, technology, and presentation formats.

Although the changes in the industries in which the company operates do not significantly impact the company, the company recognizes the importance of managing business risks arising from changes in both internal and external factors. The company has implemented systematic risk management, including monitoring, precautions, and continuous risk mitigation measures. To guide operations, the company regularly monitors, evaluates, and reviews risks in alignment with the changing internal and external environments.

728 · Description: Volatility in the industry in which the company operates · Info category: STRATEGIC_RISK
Personnel dependency risk

The company places great importance on all personnel as it is a service business that relies heavily on human resources. Therefore, the company has a plan to retain skilled and knowledgeable personnel to mitigate the risk of losing them to competitors in the same industry, to clients seeking in-house event organization, or to employees leaving to establish similar businesses. This is achieved by encouraging personnel to continuously develop their skills and knowledge both internally and externally.

There might be a loss of personnel to competitors in the same industry, a loss of personnel to In-house event organization for clients, or even personnel resigning to operate a business of the same nature.

Encourage personnel to continuously develop their knowledge, abilities, and work skills both internally and externally. Implement modern information technology systems that align with operations to enhance work management efficiency. Consider job promotions for personnel at all levels to foster career advancement, stability, morale, and motivation in their work. In conjunction, provide appropriate and sufficient welfare benefits to personnel. Additionally, organize activities that encourage personnel participation and foster a sense of belonging between personnel and the company. This is because personnel are crucial to driving the company's business growth, progress, and sustainability.

738 · Description: Reliance on employees in key positions · Info category: OPERATIONAL_RISK · 739 · Description: Shortage or reliance on skilled workers · Info category: OPERATIONAL_RISK
Employee/contractor performance risk

Although the company has strict and rigorous operational control measures in place, along with meticulous accident prevention measures for events, there is still a risk of accidents occurring at any time during operations.

Affecting the company's image if employees are injured at work, including customers may lose confidence in the company in the long run.

The company recognizes the importance of this matter and has a risk mitigation and control plan in place. This includes establishing strict work procedures, rigorous inspections by responsible supervisors, and selecting contractors with high work standards. These measures aim to ensure the safety and well-being of employees, contractors, visitors, and external personnel. Additionally, for outdoor events or those with a large number of attendees, the company's policy mandates that business units obtain third-party liability insurance to mitigate liability in case of accidents or unforeseen events.

742 · Description: Human error in business operations · Info category: OPERATIONAL_RISK · 749 · Description: Safety, occupational health, and working environment · Info category: OPERATIONAL_RISK
Risks arising from natural disasters

Currently, natural changes are more volatile and unpredictable, occurring more frequently and often with greater intensity than in the past. Sometimes, this may affect the operation or organization of marketing activities. However, the company prioritizes and monitors news and events related to natural disasters to plan in advance. This minimizes risks that may impact client events, especially in areas where the company will be operating. We assess the situation and find ways to prevent or avoid potential dangers in all circumstances. This ensures the safety of the event as well as the safety of the attendees.

Affecting work or marketing activities, which may lead to a loss of the company's main revenue.

Risk mitigation measures are in place during both the installation and operational phases of the event. This includes event insurance and insurance coverage for participants, particularly for large-scale events or those deemed necessary by the company. This provides an additional layer of assurance and confidence for both clients and attendees.

750 · Description: Climate change and disasters · Info category: OPERATIONAL_RISK
Data or computer system security and cyber attacks

Conducting business today increasingly relies on technology and digital information, including connecting devices and departments within the company through the internet. This results in business operations being at risk of cyber threats.

Theft of trade secrets, financial information, and personal data, which could damage the reputation and credibility of the company.

The company has established an information technology usage policy and a cybersecurity plan that covers the use and prevention of major cyber threats to the company, such as setting data access rights, installing systems and equipment to prevent intrusions (Firewall) and monitoring threat activities. The company has also defined a system operation inspection cycle, with system administrators to control operations and solve problems that may arise at all times. The company also continuously develops Hardware and Software systems to be up-to-date and support new forms of cybercrime. There is a system to prevent unauthorized access to information, penetration testing, and vulnerability assessments to ensure that the systems in use can effectively prevent threats. The company has also established a contingency plan in case of an event that causes the system to shut down (Disaster Recovery Plan: DRP) to protect the company's critical data from threats and risks, both internal and external, whether intentional or unintentional. This is also to reduce the damage that may arise from security breaches and to maintain the ability to conduct business continuously.

744 · Description: Information security and cyber-attack · Info category: OPERATIONAL_RISK
Corruption

The company is committed to conducting business with honesty, fairness, transparency, and good corporate governance. We uphold ethics and morality as the foundation of our business operations and will not tolerate any actions that may lead to fraud and corruption.

Impact on the company's reputation for conducting business that is not based on integrity, fairness, and transparency. Failure to comply with good corporate governance principles, lack of ethics and morals, which are essential in conducting business, leading to corruption.

The company has anti-corruption measures in place to help mitigate the risks that may lead to corruption within the organization. These measures include designing and operating under an appropriate internal control framework, as well as fostering awareness and values of anti-corruption among the company's personnel. The company has announced its anti-corruption and anti-bribery policy to all employees and strictly enforces it. Additionally, the company has issued a code of conduct for business partners to inform employees and partners of the company about the company's stance against any form of corruption.

This includes a whistle-blowing policy, which serves as a tool to enable the company to be informed of illegal activities, ethical violations, or misconduct by individuals within the organization that may indicate corruption, both from employees and all stakeholders.

In addition, the company is in the process of studying and preparing to participate in the declaration of intent for the Thai Private Sector Collective Action Coalition Against Corruption (CAC), along with sending personnel to attend training courses on anti-corruption organized by various institutions. This is to ensure that personnel have knowledge and understanding of ethics and are aware of anti-corruption in all forms.

754 · Description: Corruption · Info category: OPERATIONAL_RISK
Financial Risk

Liquidity risk arises from the possibility that the company may not be able to manage its working capital cash flow sufficiently to meet its financial obligations when they are due. This is especially true during periods of simultaneous large-scale projects that require high capital investment or during periods of economic volatility.

• Continuous lack of liquidity in business operations and investments in key projects.

• Affects financial credibility and relationships with business partners.

• May require raising funds with higher financing costs.

• Impacts the ability to compete and secure new projects.

• Cash flow planning and monitoring by preparing cash flow forecasts, regularly monitoring and analyzing actual cash flow deviations against forecasts, and developing contingency plans for liquidity to accommodate emergencies.

• Working capital management by improving policies and processes for managing trade receivables by setting appropriate payment terms, increasing efficiency in monitoring and expediting debt collection, and reducing the collection period.

• Arranging backup funding sources by considering the issuance of short-term debt instruments to increase flexibility in liquidity management and procuring revolving credit lines from multiple financial institutions.

1724 · Description: Liquidity risk · Info category: FINANCIAL_RISK
Financial Risk

As the group imports equipment and technology from abroad, as well as expands its business into foreign customer markets, the company has revenues and expenses in foreign currencies. Exchange rate fluctuations therefore affect the company's costs, revenues, and profits.

• Uncertainty in the cost of importing equipment and materials from abroad.

• Fluctuation of service revenue from abroad when converted into Thai Baht.

• Potential losses from exchange rates that affect finances.

• Enter into a forward contract for high-value transactions.

• Regularly monitor and analyze exchange rate trends.

• Consider adjusting the prices of goods and services when there is a significant change in exchange rates.

764 · Description: Fluctuation in exchange rates, interest rates, or the inflation rate · Info category: FINANCIAL_RISK
Financial Risk

The company utilizes loans from financial institutions for project investments and working capital. Consequently, fluctuations in interest rates directly impact the company's financial costs and profitability, particularly in situations where interest rates exhibit an upward trend due to the central bank's monetary policies.

• Increase interest expenses and financial costs

• Reduce profitability

• May result in a breach of financial covenants in loan agreements

• Managing loan structure and interest rates.

• Monitoring and forecasting interest rate trends of the Bank of Thailand.

• Enhancing cash flow management by utilizing excess cash to prepay loans to reduce interest expenses.

• Considering alternative fundraising options through capital markets to reduce reliance on borrowing.

764 · Description: Fluctuation in exchange rates, interest rates, or the inflation rate · Info category: FINANCIAL_RISK
Financial Risk

The company provides trade credit to both public and private sector customers, which carries the risk that customers may not be able to make payments according to the agreed terms, especially during an economic slowdown.

• Problems with overdue and bad debts affect the company's cash flow and liquidity.

• Increase the cost of debt monitoring and collection.

• May need to provide for doubtful debts that affect operating results.

• Affect the ability to pay debts to financial institutions and trade creditors.

• Establish a customer credit rating system based on financial position, payment history, and other factors.

• Establish appropriate credit policies and credit limits based on the risk level of each customer. Review and update risk assessments regularly at least once a year.

• Consider adjusting payment terms to suit the customer's risk, such as collecting advance deposits or installment payments based on work progress.

767 · Other name: Credit Risk · Description: Other · Info category: FINANCIAL_RISK
Legal and Regulatory Risks

This law defines the principles and regulatory measures for protecting personal data, whether it belongs to customers, partners, or employees, to prevent the violation of rights and ensure that the company operates ethically. Therefore, the company has appointed a Personal Data Protection Committee to oversee and prepare various plans. This includes analyzing and improving work processes, establishing policies and practices in accordance with legal requirements, and implementing strict controls to safeguard the personal data of customers, partners, and employees. These measures ensure data security, stability, and transparency to comply with the Personal Data Protection Act B.E. 2562.

The company has established various measures to define the objectives, conditions, and notifications for consent, data collection, data usage, and disclosure of personal data in accordance with legal requirements. Additionally, the company employs high-standard security systems, both in terms of technology and processes, to prevent the theft of confidential information. We also develop personnel at all levels to ensure that the company maintains standardized data security measures. These measures include the installation of firewalls and intrusion detection software, the use of data encryption technology, the installation of effective anti-virus software, and the assignment of access rights based on user levels. Further details can be found in the company's privacy policy on our website.

The nature of risks related to personal data protection in the company can be categorized into several types, considering their sources and potential impacts, as follows:

1. Compliance Risk

• Non-compliance with the Personal Data Protection Act (PDPA) or relevant laws in the countries where the company operates.

• Lack of standardized personal data management processes, such as obtaining consent, data collection, usage, and disclosure.

• Failure to prepare necessary documents or reports, such as a Privacy Policy or Data Processing Records.

2. Technology Risk

• Cyberattacks, such as data breaches, malware infections, or ransomware attacks.

• Inadequate data protection systems, such as encryption or access control.

• Vulnerabilities in software or network systems used to store or process data.

3. Operational and Human Risk

• Employee errors, such as sending information to the wrong person or sharing data without authorization.

• Insufficient employee training on personal data protection policies and regulations.

• Unauthorized use of personal data or breach of confidentiality by authorized personnel.

4. Third-Party Risk

• Failure of third-party vendors or partners to comply with data protection requirements.

• Contracts with third parties that do not adequately address personal data protection.

• Transferring data abroad without appropriate safeguards.

5. Reputational Risk

• Personal data breaches that impact the trust of customers, investors, or partners.

• Negative publicity surrounding a data breach that could damage the company's public reputation.

6. Financial Risk

• Fines or lawsuits in case of legal violations, such as penalties under PDPA or other personal data protection laws.

• Costs associated with managing data breach incidents, such as investigation or remediation expenses for affected individuals.

1. Legal Impact

• Legal Adjustments or Penalties: Companies may be subject to substantial fines under laws such as the Personal Data Protection Act (PDPA) or similar laws in other countries, such as the GDPR in Europe, where fines can reach millions of baht or depend on the company's revenue.

• Civil Litigation: Affected individuals may file lawsuits seeking damages from the company.

• Intensified Scrutiny: Regulatory agencies may closely scrutinize the company's systems and operations, resulting in costs and operational delays.

2. Financial Impact

• Incident Management Costs: Costs are incurred in investigating data breaches, remediating affected individuals, hiring cybersecurity experts, and improving security systems.

• Loss of Revenue: Customers or service users may lose confidence and switch to competitors' services.

3. Reputational Impact

• Customer Confidence: The leakage of personal information will reduce the trust of customers and business partners, which may result in the loss of existing customers and the inability to attract new ones.

• Negative news: Data breaches or violations may become a media issue, affecting the company's image both in the short and long term.

• Difficulty in Finding Partners: Other companies may be hesitant to do business with companies that have a poor track record of data management.

4. Operational Impact

• System Disruption: Cyber attacks, such as ransomware, can disrupt a company's IT systems, resulting in an inability to provide services to customers.

• Increased workload: Investigating and remediating data breaches will increase the workload of internal teams.

• Loss of Resources: Policy changes and internal system improvements can be time-consuming and resource-intensive.

5. Internal Impact

• Employee Morale Decline: Employees may feel pressured and insecure in their job roles, especially if the risk arises from employee error.

• Internal Organizational Conflict: Conflicts may arise between teams or departments responsible for the incident.

• Resignation of Key Employees: If a company experiences recurring problems, it may lead to the resignation of talented employees.

6. Social and Partner Impact

• Personal data of external parties is compromised: such as customers, shareholders, or business partners, which may lead to disadvantages or data misuse.

• Loss of trust in the industry: The incident may reduce the credibility of the entire industry to which the company belongs.

Measures to manage and mitigate risks related to the protection of personal data in the company that have been implemented are as follows:

1. Compliance Measures -

• Establishing a Privacy Policy: Specifying guidelines for the collection, use, and disclosure of personal data in all cases to serve as a correct practice. This includes informing customers and employees of their legal rights.

• Appointing a Data Protection Officer (DPO): To oversee compliance with personal data protection laws.

2. Technical and Security Measures

• Data Encryption: Mandating data encryption for confidential information to prevent unauthorized access. -

• Access Control System: Defining access privileges to important data only to individuals who need to access it. -

• Firewall and Threat Detection Installation: To prevent cyberattacks such as hacking or ransomware.

• Data Backup: Regular data backups are performed. In the event of an emergency, data can be recovered promptly without causing damage to the company.

• Penetration Testing: Vulnerability assessments of cybersecurity systems, testing attack methods such as Phishing Email or various scams, including providing knowledge to test against various cyber threats.

3. Process and Management Measures

• Clearly defining rights and responsibilities by defining the roles of employees in managing personal data.

• Development of an Incident Response Plan to manage and mitigate the impact of data breaches quickly.

• Internal Audit: An internal audit unit regularly reviews compliance with relevant policies, rules, regulations, and requirements.

• Third-Party Management: Setting terms and conditions in contracts with partners, such as data processing according to standards.

• Continuous Improvement: Regular risk assessments by the risk management committee to review processes and risk mitigation measures to adapt to rapidly changing threats.

• Learning from past incidents by analyzing the causes to improve processes for greater efficiency.

• Monitoring new laws and practices to adapt to new laws and standards that may arise in the future. Implementing these measures can foster trust from customers, partners, and shareholders, as well as create a positive image for the company in the long run.

760 · Other name: Personal Data Protection Act B.E. 2562 · Description: Other · Info category: COMPLIANCE_RISK
Legal and Regulatory Risks

1. Litigation with Advance Opportunities Fund (AO Fund) and Advance Opportunities Fund 1 (AO Fund 1)

AO Fund and AO Fund 1 filed a petition with the Singapore International Arbitration Centre, alleging that the Company breached the agreement to pay fees for the issuance of convertible debentures, demanding the Company to pay issuance fees of 7.5 million baht, calculated at 5% of the amount of 150,000,000 baht, and to redeem convertible debentures worth 50 million baht, along with interest at the rate of 5% per annum. The Company received 50 million baht from the issuance of the first series of convertible debentures out of the total amount of 150 million baht. Therefore, the 5% fee should only be charged at 2.5 million baht. The Company appointed a lawyer to submit a statement of defense to the Singapore International Arbitration Centre on March 15, 2023, raising the defense that the Petitioners were not entitled to claim the full amount of fees from the Company.


Progress

On March 15, 2023, AO Fund and AO Fund 1 (“Petitioners”) filed a petition with the Civil Court to enforce debt payment according to the arbitration award of the Singapore International Arbitration Centre. Subsequently, the Company submitted an objection along with details and reasons, including a petition requesting the President of the Supreme Court, Specialised Division, to determine whether this case falls under the jurisdiction of the Civil Court or the Central Intellectual Property and International Trade Court. Later, on October 21, 2023, the Court issued a ruling by the President of the Supreme Court, Specialised Division, determining that this case falls under the jurisdiction of the Central Intellectual Property and International Trade Court and ordering the transfer of the case to the Central Intellectual Property and International Trade Court.


The Central Intellectual Property and International Trade Court has scheduled a preliminary hearing for January 27, 2024.


2. Central Corruption and Misconduct Case between the Public Prosecutor, Office of the Special Prosecutor for Corruption Cases 1, and CMO Public Company Limited

On December 13, 2022, the Company was indicted by the public prosecutor in a criminal case at the Central Criminal Court for Corruption and Misconduct Cases, appearing as Black Case No.213/2566, between the Public Prosecutor, Office of the Special Prosecutor for Corruption Cases 1, Plaintiff, and CMO Public Company Limited, Defendant.


The Company, as the defendant, would like to clarify the facts and content of the case without affecting the merits of the case, as a disclosure of information to investors and shareholders, with the following details:


• Around 2011, the Cabinet approved in principle for Thailand to participate in the Universal Exhibition Milano 2015 in Milan, Italy, from May 1 to October 31, 2015, assigning the Ministry of Agriculture and Cooperatives as the main agency responsible for participation with a budget of 736,890,000 baht.

• On November 8, 2013, the Special Procurement Committee jointly considered and selected a list of 10 companies and juristic persons to invite to submit proposals.

• On November 21, 2013, the National Anti-Corruption Commission (NACC) received an allegation (anonymous complaint) regarding the Universal Exhibition Milano 2015 (EXPO MILANO 2015, ITALY).

• On November 29, 2013, 2 companies expressed their intention to submit proposals: 1. The Company and Consortium A.

• On December 16, 2013, the submission of technical and price proposals along with bid security was scheduled.

• On December 19-20, 2013, both juristic persons presented their proposals, and the Procurement Committee selected Consortium A as the winner.

• On March 17, 2023, the NACC notified the Company of allegations, alleging that the Company, through its authorized directors at that time, colluded with Consortium A in submitting a bid for the purpose of benefiting Consortium A to be eligible to enter into a contract with the Office of the Permanent Secretary, Ministry of Agriculture and Cooperatives, by avoiding fair price competition. Later, in 2016, Mr. B, one of the founders of Consortium A, became a major shareholder of the Company, and on May 3, 2017, he became a director of the Company.

• Subsequently, on April 18, 2023, the Company submitted a clarification to the NACC, clarifying and refuting all allegations. The main point is that the Company submitted its bid fairly and transparently, there was never any negotiation or agreement, the proposal was presented by senior executives of the Company, and the detailed design of the proposal was prepared with aesthetics appropriate for an international event.

• On November 15, 2022, the NACC assigned an official to file a complaint with the investigating officer at Nang Loeng Police Station, accusing a total of 4 juristic persons and 2 individuals.

• Subsequently, the investigating officer submitted the case files to the public prosecutor, and on December 13, 2022, the public prosecutor issued an order to indict the Company.

• On December 15, 2022, the public prosecutor issued an order not to prosecute 2 juristic persons. As for the other juristic person and 2 individuals, the investigating officer was unable to bring them to court for prosecution within the statute of limitations, which was December 16, 2022.

• All the circumstances and events that occurred involved several government officials, documents, and individuals, but in the end, only one company was prosecuted.


Progress

This case has gone through the trial and witness examination process. On September 24, 2023, the Court ruled to dismiss the plaintiff's case. Currently, the prosecutor has filed an appeal against the judgment. The company will exercise its legal rights to appeal and submit a counter-appeal in accordance with the following procedures.


3. Case of dispute with employees

On October 16, 2023, an employee of the Company's subsidiary filed a lawsuit against the subsidiary in the Central Labour Court, alleging unfair dismissal and claiming wages, advance notice, severance pay, and damages for unfair dismissal. The fact is that the employee and the subsidiary had negotiated and agreed to help each other. If the employee voluntarily resigned, the subsidiary would pay monthly assistance. After several meetings and discussions, the employee agreed to voluntarily resign and receive monthly assistance. Later, it appeared that the employee filed a lawsuit with the Central Labour Court, alleging that the subsidiary forced and threatened the employee to sign the resignation letter. Based on these facts, the subsidiary will proceed with the legal defense in this case.

-

-

760 · Other name: Legal Disputes · Description: Other · Info category: COMPLIANCE_RISK

Risks to Securities Holders' Investment

Risk Register

Risk NameRisk CharacteristicsConsequencesManagement MeasuresRelated Risk Factors
Shareholder Investment Risk

Currently, the Company has separated the roles of the Chairman of the Board of Directors and the Chief Executive Officer. However, the Company's Board structure consists of 4 independent directors out of a total of 8 directors, which is equivalent to half of the total Board members. This creates a balance of power within the Board. Additionally, there is an Audit Committee comprising 3 independent directors, each of whom possesses knowledge and expertise, enabling them to effectively review the Company's operations for greater transparency. They can also balance the power in presenting matters for consideration at the shareholders' meeting to a certain extent. Moreover, the Group has established regulations for transactions involving directors, major shareholders, or persons with controlling power in the business, as well as individuals who may have conflicts of interest or be interested parties in such transactions. These individuals are prohibited from approving such transactions to mitigate potential risks. The Company's organizational structure comprises the Board of Directors and sub-committees, namely the Executive Committee, the Audit Committee, the Nomination and Remuneration Committee, and the Risk Management Committee. The scope of authority and responsibilities of each committee is clearly defined in their respective charters, ensuring that the Company's operating system is standardized and easily auditable.

-

-

768 · Description: Return from investment of securities holder · Info category: HOLDER_RISK
Contents